I went into Smile for the Cameras expecting a full-blown slasher/horror thrill ride—something bloody, tense, and in line with the genre’s classic "final girl" tropes. What I got was…not quite that.
The premise is undeniably intriguing: Ella Winters, once a
scream queen icon and the sole survivor of a cult classic slasher film, returns
to the spotlight decades later for a reunion documentary. But secrets buried on
the original set are unearthed when cast members begin dying in eerily familiar
ways. Sounds like a recipe for a fast-paced, suspenseful slasher, right?
Well, not exactly.
The book is divided into three parts—then, now,
and excerpts from the Grad Night script. While this structure is a cool
concept in theory, it can be confusing in execution. You’ll definitely need to
pay attention to chapter headings or risk getting lost. That said, it does add
an atmospheric, meta vibe that fans of horror movie nostalgia might appreciate.
The issue, for me, lies in the pacing and plot repetition.
The first half of the novel feels like a rehash of the same beats—Ella's guilt,
the group's shared secret, and the tension between the characters—without much
progression. It doesn't really lean into the slasher potential, and there's a
noticeable lack of mystery or suspense until the final act. Even then, the
"big reveal" feels underwhelming, delivered mostly through dialogue
with minimal action.
In truth, I’d categorize this more as a slow-burn drama with
thriller undertones rather than a true horror or mystery. It has emotional
weight, explores the trauma of fame and past choices, and asks interesting
questions about legacy and guilt. But if you’re looking for scares, chills, or
edge-of-your-seat thrills, you might want to lower your expectations.
If you go in expecting more character drama than carnage, Smile
for the Cameras could work for you. Just don’t expect it to play by the
rules of the genre it’s referencing.
Comments
Post a Comment