Mia Ballard’s Shy Girl arrived wrapped in controversy long before many readers ever opened the first page. I received an ARC through NetGalley, where I often review upcoming releases, and this title had already built a strong buzz across multiple reader groups. Naturally, it landed high on my reading list. Before I even had the chance to begin, the publisher pulled the book entirely after a The New York Times article alleged that the novel had been written 78% by AI. The contract was dropped, the internet erupted, and Shy Girl became less about horror fiction and more about the growing war between authors, readers, and the question of AI in publishing. Because of that controversy, I knew I absolutely needed to read it while I still had access. The premise is strong: Gia, lonely, financially struggling, and emotionally vulnerable, agrees to an unusual sugar-dating arrangement with a wealthy man named Nathan. His demands are simple but disturbing—wear the collar, drink from the bow...